Tuesday, December 25, 2012

Simplicity




The power of the thought, the elegance of the concept, the simplicity in expression. So simple, it can arguably be termed boring. Perhaps it is being dismissed as such, which is a pity. Indian Cities are full of unassigned voids  awaiting a Paley Park-like catalyst.

At one level it is a pocket garden/ public space. At another level, it is -to me- the willingness to accept simple interventions that end up having a profound impact on the way we see cities, nature and people.








I have been looking at it for years, yet it beguiles me.

As Ghalib concluded, "...yun hota toh kya hota..."

Sunday, September 23, 2012

A Place in the Shade


The name Borivali recalls the Zizyphus trees (Bor in Marathi) which were abundant till about ten years ago. Borivali is my hometown, specifically Mandapeshwar or Mt. Poinsur. The place contains varied marks of history.  The 65 million years old landscape with yielded itself in the 5th Century CE to the chisel marks of the stone carver at Mandapeshwar- a Buddhist era outpost along the Dahisar river.  Perhaps then the Dahisar river flowed closer to the caves. It is said, till the late 1960s, crocodiles apparently resided along the river. Nearby, was an old bridge- perhaps late 17th Century CE- a lifeline across a river prone to floods. A thousand years ago, monks, wayfarers and merchants camped at Mandapeshwar while negotiating the route between Kanheri and the port of Sopara (present day Nala Sopara). Later, so did the Portguese invaders who came here from Bassein (Vasai) in the mid-16th century CE, followed by Jesuit priests in the mid-19th century.  Over the years, Mandapeshwar became Montpazier and then Mt. Poinsur.  

In this setting, Jeevan Bima Nagar, a township built by the Life Insurance Corporation of India between 1974-78 sits on a small hillock. Its slopes gradually merge with the not-too far away mangroves, tidal flats and salt pans. The layout of the colony bears influences of distinct cultures on a now famous and respected architect. It has a Radburn-like Cul-de-sac arrangement which ends into a central green. Like the traditional Indian settlements, there is no boundary wall to the township. The houses and floor plans with cascading terraces and spilt windows visually connect the residents with the existing mango orchard amidst which the majority of buildings were nestled. Contact with nature through an aperture is a design leitmotif here.


While there is no attempt to acknowledge the larger ecology and history in the Masterplan, the architect seems have enjoyed siting buildings on the sloping land. The geometries of the hill and the layout plan gave ample opportunity to demonstrate this. It created interesting possibilities like pedestrian alleys between buildings, split level entrances and a sense of relative high and low elevations which could stimulate a child’s imagination. Dry pitched walls became forts of warring kings and “Chor Police” could be played throughout the colony without having to worry about the main road traffic.

There were no badminton courts or netted cricket pitches. The rain and sun dictated the games of the season. The road was the arena and there were a few mud pockets at places to create the slush so important for football and a beating from your mother. There was no lawn. We had sun-loving hardy grasses in the unassigned spaces between buildings which became small maidans. They also substituted as congregation spaces. There was a creative use of open space, because the intent of the space was not thrust upon its residents by being "landscaped".

One had to learn how to climb trees, how to hit a six that cleared the canopy of the Pangara tree and where that snake hole was, in that culvert. There were wells which became source of water in particularly dry summers (twice) and a silent testimony to the magic of groundwater. Every child had a version of how water came to be in the well. We weren’t yet exposed to the subject of Environmental science.

My grandfather used to take long walks along unpaved trails- a pagdandi.  He would reach out and break a sturdy twig, and the next day I would have my bow. The arrows came from the broomsticks. We aimed to hit our enemy but we also learned to duck and avoid injury. We learned to jump on and tackle where leaves were littered and the banyan roots hung. Today the idea of an unpaved walkway is unpardonable, a safety floor mandatory and a jungle gym necessary.

Somewhere down the line, our parents jobs started paying better. Scooters and cars clogged our cricket pitches. Parking lots overtook our maidans. Buildings acquired compound walls and the space between buildings became filthy backyards. The jaalis unfortunately got built-up, and the window shutters devolved into sliding windows which brought in heat. A naturally cool place, Jeevan Bima Nagar started using air conditioners as the surrounding greens outside the colony gave way to rapid urbanization.  

The Dahisar river too has witnessed a change in relation to the Mandapeshwar Caves.  Today it is about 800 metres further to the east, obscured by a burgeoning Shivaji Nagar Colony. My family's  domestic backbone-Parvati bai- was a construction worker from Satara, who helped build the colony 35 years ago. Today, many like her are indispensible to the families that live in Jeevan Bima Nagar and surrounding colonies. It is where the “other half” of our lives live. They keep their colony clean and wistfully remember when the river used to flood their homes. The landscape has bound different destinies together.

The Maratha-era bridge is now gone, and the tempestuous river lies channelized, till it abates as a tidal estuary and meets the mangroves. The river today has few traces of its bygone picturesque character and is highly polluted with industrial effluents, sewage and stormwater. In recent times it had narrowed down and silted up. After the 2005 Maharashtra floods, where more than a 100 people lost their lives, the local corporation undertook a de-silting and widening project to clean up the river and prevent future flooding. There are occasional stirrings regarding the beautification/ environmental improvement of the river. The caves spring to life on Shivaratri, when the precinct is cleaned and devotees throng to seek blessings. Otherwise, it alternates as a parking lot for autorickshaws and the occasional drunken brawls. There are few interested souls in the Shivaji Nagar slums and surrounding colonies who bother with its heritage status.  The Archeological survey‘s guardianship has prevented the misuse of the place. In the last few years, the salt pans have been claimed for resorts and slums proliferate as vote banks. All this is a clear nexus with the CRZ rules. The salt makers have gone into the pages of history like the monks. The caves thankfully haven’t vanished.

Recently  the 19-acre central green area- absolute wilderness- in the colony was in threat of acquisition by market forces.  Fringe open spaces continue to be lopped off and sold to builders. Nostalgia has prompted residents to re-organize street-side games and Sunday-events for children. The community is waking up to the beauty of having undefined and hence multipurpose open spaces. The mango trees still yield fruit, albeit lesser than before. No buildings or roads disturb them as they age gracefully. But the urge to break the compound walls and let children and pets wander is an idea whose time has gone.

All of this is proof that the way we now think of boundaries and segregations has changed and needs to be integrated as experiences rather than lifeless landuses.

It does not take a degree in Architecture to realize that my house and my colony weave the outdoor and Indoor seamlessly. I did not have to look far to understand phrases like borrowed view, indirect lighting, diffused sun,  vista, threshold, transition space. It does not need a course in climatology and History of Indian Architecture to know that the buildings were oriented to harness sea breeze and keep out the sun. The windows, by their design allowed an adult and a kid to see the outdoors, and kept the rain out. The jaali brought in diffused light that had bounced off a rough plastered white blank wall of the adjoining building. The step outside each door on each floor created an aangan-like place where the fishmonger, salt seller and the milkman would navigate between noisy kids and elderly neighbours. Sight sound and smell is an integral part of living here.

It tells us that perhaps we can blur the distinction between landscape and architecture- an imagination of Architecture as a non-sanitized, inclusive environment.

This project has been relegated to a footnote status in the large body of work by the architect-Charles Correa. For me, this is one of my best references when I look for the Place of Nature in the City of the Future.

(Illustrated talk presented at the ISOLA 2012 Conference- Bhopal under Panorama: The Place of Nature in Tomorrow's City")

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

The futility of knowing what a Building will be


"We know what our buildings are going to be", is right now the biggest statement that is floating all around wherever I go. There is a wide ocean of possibilities that lies between Knowing and Seeking Architecture. The seeking is the journey. The knowing, is just one pit-stop on the way.

Even then, what does it take to "know " what a building ought to be? Is it enough if it creates an enclosure, functionally organizes its indoor usage and carries notions of aesthetics which are as fickle as the client's mind? Is it enough to declare that the building is planned for "flexibility of use"? Or that it superficially alludes to a sense of Place?

The design of a building cannot be just driven by the knowledge/ one's command of climatology/daylighting/floor use efficiency/ quick buildability although these are very valid parameters for a building to exist. Nor can its parts be "assigned" to various consultants from allied fields to make the building work.

If Louis Kahn's "Ask the brick what it wants to be" is any yardstick, then it takes more than just bricks and mortar to know what a building ought to be. 

The idea of declaring that one knows what the building should be /will be is like saying that we breathe with our nose. Though factually correct, the breath through the nose is the basis for engaging with Prana - vital Life.  This happens regardless of whose nose it is, or where the air is coming from. Likewise, the act of making a building has to engage the designer and the user's senses. It can only get better if it manages to communicate some poetics of Space and engages with the land on which it sits.

This is that vital Life- Prana- necessary for creating a distinction between a Building (a mere shell which panders to function aesthetics and climate) and Architecture.

There is no other way. 

Preferring Feel over Feeling is symptomatic of the various forms of disconnect we see around us, paradoxically enabled by technological connectivity. It has percolated into design of spaces, and is becoming responsible for further catalyzing the disconnect.

The sooner this is grasped...the better. Only then will we see the renaissance of Architecture with Soul. 


Saturday, May 5, 2012

Babumoshaai!!!!!!!!!


"Babumoshaai!!!"  Probably the most popular one-word dialogue ever uttered in Indian Cinema, with a great visual recall.

Its voice... Rajesh Khanna, the first Superstar of Hindi Cinema, and arguably Indian Cinema.

Rajesh Khanna is not the sort of actor, in my opinion, to have a great recall value, especially when one is not from either of the generations, ones  which idolised him and ones which continued the wake. But a quick survey of his repertoire given in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rajesh_Khanna is enough evidence of what he has tried to do as an actor and the euphoria he generated as a superstar. The critical comparison with Kamal Hassan for the same role is even more remarkable (Ref: Sivappu Rojakkal/Red Rose).

What pains even a non-fan of Kaka, as he is fondly called and parodied, is the current ad for Havell Fans. We see a very old Kaka, nattily dressed recalling the days of yore where true Superstardom was defined by the adoration of the fans. A beautiful montage of flashbacks  forms the backdrop for this giant of a Thespian, now old, feeble and perhaps standing on his own legs with the determinism that characterizes true human beings.

 "Mujhse mere fans koi nahi cheen sakta" he summarizes, and the camera pans out to see an auditorium of "fans"...the revolving kind. It looks clever and cheeky at first, and then the disgust sinks in. 

What was the director thinking? What was Havell as a company thinking? Commodification of persona is not new to Indian television. But this plumbs to new low. A new threshold of "Sick".

Why did you do an ad like this Kaka? Is it the pain of watching your greatest rival and successor to the mantle of "Superstar" hawk everything from cultural tourism to chawanprash in every third ad that comes on TV? Is it because someone with a personal agenda massaged your Capricornian ego and said you could do it too, and you gave in? 

Advertisements need to be made in good taste, especially when the person endorsing the product is a little more accomplished than most others around. Else its becomes a pathetic commercialization. Perhaps one of the slickest ad's ever made in India for is BPL TV by Rakesh Omprakash Mehra more than a decade ago and featuring Amitabh Bachchan- your greatest rival and successor. But then, it has been consistently downhill since then for him. Another good set of ad's in the last two years have been by Abhinay Deo, featuring his father Ramesh Deo. Thankfully, he is extremely choosy.

The triangle of Amitabh Bachchan, Ramesh Deo and Rajesh Khanna gave us Anand. In the movie, your candle went out in a blaze that it is one of Indian Cinema's greatest endings ever.

Please remember this Kaka when you say "Theek Hai Re..." to the next advertisement that comes your way. But then, it is your choice, as it is your life and you are its best judge.

I say all this even though I am not a great fan by the yardsticks of fan-dom that you have created..


Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Flora of Mumbai-2

Continuing the tryst with Flora with an effort to understand Floristic biodiversity and landscape character, atleast three sources of information have been useful to view the Floristic composition of the landscape of the Mumbai region:

  1. BOTANICAL REGION: A Botanical region is roughly similar to the geographical regions ( i.e. Malabar, Deccan, Gangetic Plains, Himalayan etc.) 
  2. Forest Type of the Mumbai region (Forest Type– the coverage/ extent of any/ all floristic types.)
  3. HISTORIC ACCOUNTS OF AGRICULTURAL AND HORTICULTURAL PRACTICES-  sourced from the Gazetteer of Bombay (SM Edwards 1909, Vol I pp 80- 125)
 FLORA OF MUMBAI- a brief summary:

With respect to the Botanical Regions of India, Mumbai comes under the Malabar region, which is continuous along the West Coast. This region is characterized by Tropical and Sub-Tropical Moist (Broadleaf) Forest type.

As per the eco-system classification of the Forest Types of India (Champion and Seth, 1931), the Mumbai region is dominated by the Sub-Tropical Moist Deciduous Forest type.

A study of the recordings in the Gazetteer of Bombay  (Vol I pp 80- 125  ) indicates a large portion of the natural landscape of the Bombay region having characteristics of a seasonal and Littoral Swamp- which is a different Forest Type.

The Manmade landscape of the erstwhile Bombay region is also recorded as a mixed palette of Horticultural practices –introduction of exotic/ non-native plant species (now naturalized), Fruit Orchards and Vegetable farming. 

The average rainfall of Mumbai - 2300 mm- coupled with its subtropical climate can sustain a broad palette of plant material, including exotics. In order to conserve the amount of water used in landscape irrigation and address native plant diversity, the preference of native and naturalized species over exotics, plays an important role. The Botanical diversity of the Mumbai region has some common parameters. 


BOTANICAL REGION
FOREST TYPE
Native Forest Type
Tropical and Sub-Tropical Moist (Broadleaf) Forest
Sub-Tropical  
 Moist Deciduous
Tropical Seasonal 
Swamp Forest
Mean Annual Rainfall
1200-3000
1900- 3000 mm
1000-2000 mm
# of Rainy Days
63-150
100-110
~ 100
# of Dry Months
3-8 months
4-6
4-6 months
Annual Mean Humidity
Upto 80%
80%
>80 %
Mean Annual Temp
24-27 C
Upto 30 C
Upto 30 C
Mean Maximum Temp
43C
40 C- 43C
-------
Natural water availability (rainfall)
/natural irrigation rate
Approx 30 mm per day for 100 days
Approx 30 mm per 
dayfor 100 days
Approx 20 mm per 
dayfor 100 days
Species Natural Occurrence:
Albizzia spp.
Dendrocalamus strictus (bamboo)
Lagerstroemia spp.
Mimusops elengi
Schleichera trijuga
Tectona grandis (teak) 10-25%
Terminalia spp.
Zizyphus jujuba
Atrocarpus spp.
Albizzia spp.
Amoora rohituka
Anona spp.
Eugenia spp.
Michelia spp.
Terminalia spp.


Borasus flabellifer
Cocos nucifera
Phoenix sylvestris
Syzygium cumini  
Mangrove scrub 

Acanthus spp. 
Avicennia spp. 
Salvadora persica


 ISSUE:
Current horticultural practice is to provide between 4 to 6 litres per sq.mt of water during establishment and reducing to approx 3-4 litres thereon. This is due to the predominant use of lawns, exotic plants, and the urge to have a manicured look.

Compare this statistic to the natural water availability in the table above.  

LESSON:
If the Mean annual rainfall is taken as the optimum water requirement for the planting, then from this, the daily water requirement can be calculated. Due to the naturalization of these species, their ability to cope with dry spells is much more than exotics. This further reduces the daily demand for water.


Flora of Mumbai

One immediate recall for the word 'Flora' in Mumbai /Bombay is the Flora Fountain. 

Its history can be traced to the 1860's a part of the then Governor Bartle Frere's efforts at municipal improvements for the city. Frere's efforts, though worlds apart, were contemporary to the City Beautiful Movement in the United States which saw some of its greatest expressions in the Chicago World's Fair. The Flora Fountain was erected at the exact place where the Church gate (named after St. Thomas Cathedral, Mumbai ) stood before its demolition along with the Mumbai Fort. It was constructed by the Agri–Horticultural Society of Western India, out of a donation by Cursetjee Fardoonjee Parekh. Designed by R. Norman Shaw, it was sculpted in imported Portland stone by James Forsythe. Originally named after Frere, the name was changed before the fountain was unveiled as Flora Fountain, named after Flora- a Roman Goddess of flowers and the season of spring whose statue adorns the top of the fountain. 

Correctly speaking, ‘Flora’ (with Capital F) and ‘flora’ (with small f) are different words. Flora represents the botanical composition of a region that gives the occurrence of species of plant material (varieties, cultivars etc. not included). "flora" is part of the phrase “flora and fauna’ usually used to depict / state the occurrence of plant and animal life.(note:‘Vegetation’ is the physical Character of plant form (tree, shrub, grass etc). Tree Shrub Grass etc are Habits of the specimen). 

The following pictures speak about the evolution of the urban space and character around the Flora Fountain. Apart from street furniture like railings, light poles, horticultural representatives of the "Flora" have also undergone changes, while Flora continues to survey the everchanging landscape beneath her gaze.


c.1880s  (columbia(dot)edu) /itc/mealac/pritchett/00routesdata/1500_1599/bombay/florafountain/florafountain.html

c.1890s (oldphotosbombay.blogspot.com)

c.1900s mumbaireadyreckoner.org

c.1910s mumbaireadyreckoner.org

c.1910s teslock.btinternet.co.uk

c.1950s team-bhp.com

c.1970s team-bhp.com

c.1990s (my(dot)opera(dot)com)

Monday, December 12, 2011

Place Name

 Continuing my fascination with  Place names some of which is listed here, my discovery of Bangalore is adding to the list.

Till now I have come across :

Pete (pronounced pay-tey)...usually ascribed to the old city. It is a synonym for "market" and is resonant with the Marathi word "Peth". (e.g. Chickapete, Chamarajapete)

Agarahara: the Brahmin quarter of a heterogenous village, or an enclave of the Brahmin community. (e.g. Roopena agrahara, Konappana agarhara). In ancient times these areas were the seats of local governance and places of education.

Palya : a local municipality headed by a Paleyagara or local chieftan under direct rule of the king. (e.g. Sadgunthepalya)

Gudi: a temple area usually having a regional prominence. (e.g. Basavanagudi...the Bull temple)

Godi:  unsure of whether it is a corruption of Gudi. If not, it supposedly means "godown" (e.g. Adugodi, Kadugodi)

Kere: lake, suffixed to places with large lakes (e.g. Arakere, Mathikere)

Uru/ Ooru: a town, sometimes a suburb in a town (e.g. Bengaluru, Alasuru , Dommaluru)

Halli: a village known for a certain speciality (e.g. Marathahalli, Bommanahalli, Billekehalli)

Sandra: supposed to be a corruption of Samdra...i.e. vast body of water (e.g. Neelasandra, Jakkasandra)

Pura : another variant to "town".

I believe there is more to unravel as one comes more in contact with the mellifluous Kannada language.